Jul 20th 2019

Interview with critic Melinda Bargreen:  Suffering as print media slide down relentlessly

by Michael Johnson

Michael Johnson is a music critic with particular interest in piano. 

Johnson worked as a reporter and editor in New York, Moscow, Paris and London over his journalism career. He covered European technology for Business Week for five years, and served nine years as chief editor of International Management magazine and was chief editor of the French technology weekly 01 Informatique. He also spent four years as Moscow correspondent of The Associated Press. He is the author of five books.

Michael Johnson is based in Bordeaux. Besides English and French he is also fluent in Russian.

You can order Michael Johnson's most recent book, a bilingual book, French and English, with drawings by Johnson:

“Portraitures and caricatures:  Conductors, Pianist, Composers”

 here.

 

The influential music critic Melinda Bargreen contributed regular reviews and features on the music scene in Seattle, Washington, for more than 30 years, only to find that her newspaper, the Seattle Times, decided to cut space for music criticism in its shrinking future. She was forced out. For the past 11 years as a free spirit, Ms. Bargreen, pianist, degrees in English literature and a composer of successful choral works, has been writing books, delivering lectures and contributing freelance reviews to her old paper. I asked her to look back on what she has learned in a lifetime of music criticism and describe what she is doing now. 

 

Question. To what degree is music criticism today a force for good …  or evil?

Answer.  These days, I wonder whether music criticism can be described as a “force” at all – given the relentless slide downward of print media, and the inability of electronic media to give readers real insight into great performance and new talent. 

 

Q. What is the impact on performers?

A. The decline of print journalism is disastrous. Unless you played your cello at the royal wedding, or just won a prestigious competition, how is a player going to make a career when there isn’t a reliable source to say how good you are? 

 

Q. But generally speaking, don’t serious critics contribute to goodness?

A. We all like to think of music criticism as bringing to light wonderful talent, participating in the thrill of discovery, giving readers the chance to be in on something exceptional. Or the “calling out” of an overhyped phenomenon that’s not really worth the kudos. But there are times when it also is a force for evil. Overpraise for the undeserving, underpraise (or no notice at all) for the venturesome. 

MJ_Bargreen
Melinda Bargreen by the interviewer Michael Johnson

 

Q.  What is the critic’s role in this circumstance?

A. At the very least, the reviewer/critic ought to be able to tell the reader more or less exactly what went on in the concert, how good or how horrible it was, and precisely why that judgment was formed. 

 

Q. Don’t your worry about the artist’s feelings?

A. I think that the minute you start thinking about how the artist will feel when he/she reads the review, you are heading down a dangerous path. A critic’s responsibility is to the reader and to the audience. Not to the artist, except that the critic owes the artist a fair and honest hearing.

 

Q. How have you adjusted to your newspaper’s decision to dump classical music criticism eleven years ago? Do they know something?

A. It’s safe to say I’m still adjusting; after all those decades it’s still difficult to think of the newspaper as “they” and not as “we.” This is an issue of ageing in every discipline, even in cases where you’d hope that the voice of experience would have value. In our society today, the voice of experience prevails about as often as the voice of reason. They’re both sotto voce.

 

Q. You must have found yourself in a difficult position, being a good-natured critic, when second-tier pianists turned up with too many bad habits, hammering the clavier for two hours. How do you stay true to your kind self?

A. There are always two ways to steer a review: the pianist was having an intermittently off night, or the pianist should go out and shoot himself/herself. I usually prefer the former. 

 

Q. How do bad recitals affect you?

A. I’ve seldom heard a completely awful piano recital. What’s usually the case is that you hear routine ho-hum Schumann and dutiful Mozart, and then maybe some Scriabin that makes you stand up and cheer. And sometimes it is impossible to be kind and still tell the truth. In that case, truth wins.

 

Q. Have you ever acted on the impulse, common to New York critics, “Aha, I’ve been waiting for decades for someone this bad!”

A. You don’t have to wait for decades! Bad performers come along all the time! 

What bothers me the most is when a much-hyped performer turns out to be terrible.

 

Q. How do you relate to the players? Are you there to help them? What happens when you seriously object to a technique or interpretation?

A. Any critic who thinks they’re there to help the players is incorrect. You are there to help the readers, not the players, by telling them as honestly and interestingly as you can what happened in the performance, why it was (or wasn’t) great or moving or dreadful.

 

Q. On a personal level, are players among your best friends? If so, how do you remain objective?

A. No, players are not among my best friends, though I am a little looser about this friendship issue now that I am not employed by the newspaper. If I am asked to lecture at a music festival (and am therefore paid by them) I am careful not to review the concert in question, but that’s about the extent of it. 

 

Q. How about looking deeper for trends and insights?

A. Yes, much more interesting for me are friendships with people inside organizations … some orchestra players, for example, who will tell me what’s going on behind the scenes and how the current maestro is regarded. Now that’s interesting!

 

Q. I once wrote about a violinist that he “fairly butchered” a Beethoven sonata. He never spoke to me again and I still feel bad, 40 years later. You received a bag of hostile mail after you slammed Andrea Bocelli. Should a critic care about wreckage he or she leaves behind?

A. In the case of Bocelli, I doubt that he ever heard about the unimpressed reception he got in Seattle; he could hear the roars of approval from the audience and if his handlers were smart, they didn’t show him negative reviews. So I have no concerns about wreckage.

 

Q. What is your view of stage antics of ambitious pianists – the swoons and hair-flicks (Khatia Buniatishvili), the miniskirts and six-inch heels (Yuja Wang), the eye makeup and winks to the audience (Lang Lang)?

A. It’s all show-biz. All three of those pianists, though, really CAN play (though in varying degrees of success in varying repertoire). No matter how short Yuja Wang’s vestigial swath of skirt becomes, no matter how vertiginous her high heels, she knows her way around the ivories (I especially like her Prokofiev), and I think she makes music more fun for a wide variety of listeners. If she couldn’t play, all the short skirts in Christendom couldn’t save her career. Same goes with the emoting of Buniatishvili, and, of course, most of all, the ultimate showman, Mr. Lang, the classical world’s answer to Liberace. 

 

Q. Are the Chinese invading us with intent? Some 40 million of their young are working on “our” repertoire? Are they mechanical players or true artists?

A. I think it’s “their turn” to discover classical music, and I just hope they leave a little room for non-Asians in the cutthroat world of music festivals, auditions, competitions, and orchestra seats. After all, we Americans “horned in” pretty thoroughly on what was originally a European tradition (classical music and the piano recital). But my view of all musicians, including Chinese newcomers, is based on talent and musicianship: if they can really play, let them! 

 

Q. Should Western musicians be afraid, even very afraid?

A. I think all musicians should be very afraid that classical music is continually being marginalized in our society, with university music departments shrinking and younger listeners/performers hampered by a lack of music education in the public schools. These are worse problems for the West than an influx of gifted musicians from another part of the world.

 

Q. How adaptable are you in today’s changing music scene? What is your view on some of the contemporary works – such as John Luther Adams, John Cage, or Stockhausen, or Berio? What happens to your gut when you hear my favorite, Salvatore Sciarrino’s Due Notturni Crudelli Il Furio, metallo? 

A. I consider myself adaptable and ready to be convinced by something good. By this I mean something that communicates to the listener something beyond the personal distress of the composer. How old-fashioned to still be looking for beauty! We hear a lot of John Luther Adams in Seattle, and I just finished reviewing for another publication his latest magnum opus “Become Desert.” It is decidedly better than the interminable “Become Ocean.” I still feel impatient, though, with what I consider “ambient music” that feels like “music to zone out by.” JL Adams is very good at what he does, and he’s sort of “flavor of the month/year/etc.” in the music establishment. But having heard both these “Becomes” more than once, I definitely feel sated.

 

Q. And as for my favorite?

A. The Sciarrino piece deserves the “Crudelli” designation, in my opinion. We may be better off not discussing what I feel in my gut, but my ears are definitely saying “No, thank you.”

 

Q. Women conductors are mounting the podium more and more in the past ten years. Are the guys in the band gritting their teeth? Will this trend last or is it a fad?

A. Well, today the “guys in the band” include a whole lot of “gals in the band”; I think the Seattle Symphony is about one-third women, possibly more, and they’re certainly not alone in that demographic trend. Women conductors who know their stuff and prove their worth are generally welcomed by players who are grateful for good artistic leadership. Maybe there are grumblings and mumblings among the players, but by and large – at least in Seattle – the “chicks with sticks” are accorded equal respect when they prove they deserve it.

I’m also noticing more and more women hired in important principal spots in major orchestras; again, this makes sense whenever it’s deserved.

 

Q.  What are your thoughts on the future of live classical music? Looking out across your audiences, isn’t most of the hair white or blue? What happens when they die?

A. Despite the fact that I share that white hair (carefully colored blonde), I feel pretty optimistic about the future of live classical music. It cannot thrive without community involvement, philanthropy, and visionary leadership; those are always vulnerable to financial vagaries and limitations. Nobody has a great crystal ball with respect to any of the arts, in my view, but I’m hopeful that the current programs of inexpensive tickets for the young will play a part in starting future listeners out on the right path. If you look to the past, the people who had the discretionary income and the time to attend classical events have always tended toward the upper end of the age spectrum. I don’t particularly think that the concert audiences as a whole have aged appreciably in the years I have been writing about music.

---

Full text of this conversation will appear in Michael Johnson’s forthcoming book of 35 interviews,  “What musicians really think”.

------

Another version of this interview appeared in Slipped Disc

END

 

 


This article is brought to you by the author who owns the copyright to the text.

Should you want to support the author’s creative work you can use the PayPal “Donate” button below.

Your donation is a transaction between you and the author. The proceeds go directly to the author’s PayPal account in full less PayPal’s commission.

Facts & Arts neither receives information about you, nor of your donation, nor does Facts & Arts receive a commission.

Facts & Arts does not pay the author, nor takes paid by the author, for the posting of the author's material on Facts & Arts. Facts & Arts finances its operations by selling advertising space.

 

 

Browse articles by author

More Music Reviews

Jul 1st 2020
EXTRACT: "Question: Are you collaborating with living composers? Answer: Yes, Scott Wollschleger sends me unfinished new works every month. Keeril Makan is working on a piano concerto. Melaine Dalibert has dedicated several recent works to me. There are more names on the horizon. But these are the three where I feel I can have a big impact on their careers, and all three write music that I feel born to play. That combination of things is important to me."
Jun 1st 2020
EXTRACT: "Question: How do you see your musical mission today? Answer: My real passion in music is to resist popularity rankings and market forces. In my view, these currents impoverish our cultural richness........."
May 1st 2020
EXTRACT: Alessandro Deljavan: "I bought a former convent 40 kilometers from Pescara, in Villamagna. It's very important for me to breathe clean air and live as simply as possible. Life in a giant city full of cars and smog is hard for me to imagine. My perspective is always to live fully. My aspirations for the best musical experiences guides my decisions and over the past several years I have had the pleasure of meeting and working with some wonderful musicians—these experiences have brought me a sense of optimism for what might lie ahead.”
Apr 16th 2020
EXTRACT: "Federico Mompou, the reclusive Catalonian composer whose calm, spare piano writing is currently enjoying a rebirth, might well look askance at any effort to pull him forward into modern mode. Such was never his genre but that’s precisely what one of his ardent admirers, pianist Maria Canyigueral, proposed to do. The result is her intriguing new CD, Avant-guarding Mompou."
Mar 22nd 2020
EXTRACT: "In our interview, Prof. Réach says he cautions his students in Barcelona to approach the Variations with care, warning them “the path will be long and will require great patience”. He has personally overcome his fear of this “masterpiece of masterpieces”, having recorded them three times and performed them in about 15 countries a total of about 150 times."
Mar 13th 2020
EXTRACT: "The 88-key piano looks headed for a major transformation in the coming decades. The mechanism under the lid is based on a 130-year-old design and many specialists believe it is time to dispense with those delicate moving parts.  As innovative Australian piano builder Wayne Stuart says, “The piano has been crying out for a rethink for over a hundred years.” "
Mar 8th 2020
EXTRACT: "Question: You have a Paris background. What do you bring to Granados to ensure Spanish flavor? Delicacy? Momentum? Singing and dancing undertones? Rubato?........Answer: First, I am profoundly European........."
Feb 15th 2020
EXTRACT: "Question: You have said that you are plagued by doubts. Is this true?.........Answer: Of course I am plagued by doubts. This is part of the artist’s life. But I continue to work and perform. I have moments of depression but I try to transform these doubts into positives. Many artists have these doubts. Some don’t talk about it. But doubt is always there."
Jan 26th 2020
EXTRACT: "QUESTION: Wouldn’t young composers of today benefit from aligning themselves with a philosophical ethos in order to find their musical voice -- as opposed to trying merely to find their own voice by drawing on imagination or personal experience?.......... ANSWER: It’s an interesting question, but open to interpretation. My impulse is to answer yes. When young I did a tremendous amount of reading in the history of aesthetics, and as a result my sense of artist -- ethos, necessity, whatever -- is not limited to post-WWII influences. One result is that I’ve never had any patience for the late-20th-century idea that art is about “personal expression.” The ancient and more enduring view is that the artist expresses what is out there to be expressed. As T.S. Eliot admirably wrote, art is an escape from personality, not an expression of it. Likewise I’ve never warmed to the idea of “finding one’s voice,” which sounds to me too much like creating an instantly recognizable trademark style that will make your music easier to market commercially."
Jan 19th 2020
EXTRACT: "It has been a long journey I enjoy re-living as I take note this year of the great Ludwig van Beethoven’s 250th birthday. As a practicing music critic and journalist from American corn country, I call myself a hick hack but I experience meltdown at almost everything the great man wrote. How can one not love Beethoven?"
Jan 9th 2020
EXTRACT: "Judith Juaregui, based in Madrid but peripatetic in her concertizing around Europe, is gaining an international audience of admirers, boosted by the brilliant pianistic colors of her Debussy, Liszt, Falla, Chopin and Mompou in her fifth CD, “Pour le Tombeau de Claude Debussy”, just out. This album was recorded at a recital in Vienna last year, her first foray into live recording, and she is  rather pleased with the result, which, she says in our interview (below), captured a “moment of honesty”. She left everything in, including the vigorous applause from the audience."
Dec 11th 2019
EXTRACTS: "The young tousle-haired pianist from the distant Minnesota, Reed Tetzloff, is building a performance career in the U.S. and Europe by steering a course through rare repertoire that is both challenging and attractive for the listener........In our email question-and-answer discussion he explains his priorities as a musician and his attraction to a wide range of repertoire."
Dec 9th 2019
Extract: "Then the house lights came up and the rest of us rushed out, relieved that it was all over."
Nov 15th 2019
Extract: "Question: Mompou was modest, yet one of his famous comments is similar to Handel’s remark that he was writing down what God dictated. Mompou said he did not think up music, he simply transmitted it. Answer: The Mompou’s idea about God was interesting. God was a great force that also could destroy his own creation, like a child who in a moment of joy treads on an ant without noticing. Mompou explained that, in his case, the music was not coming from inside to outside, but the opposite way, from outside to the inside, with him being the intermediary of this flow, as a kind of medium. Mompou felt embarrassed to be called on stage after a performance of his music. He was convinced that if the work was really good, it was not entirely created by himself. 
Oct 27th 2019
Composer Kyle Gann’s new book ‘The Arithmetic of Listening’ analyzes microtonality and makes a plea for the music fraternity to open its ears to the new directions possible. After 22 years of teaching at Bard College in the eastern United States, Gann has become a guru or godfather of new music, and continues to produce captivating compositions, as in his new two-CD album ‘Hyperchromatica’. His latest book analyzes and explains tuning theory. In this interview he asserts that new music that gets the attention of publishers and producers today is mostly “derivative crap”. The golden age of “downtown” music from 1960 to 2000 assembled “a bunch of escapees from the twin hells of academia and corporate commercialism”.
Oct 21st 2019
EXTRACT: "A powerful new talent from Italy, Alessandro Deljavan, made his U.S. East Coast debut October 19, with a magnificent reading of the Brahms Piano concerto No. 2 under conductor Benjamin Zander and the Boston Philharmonic Orchestra."
Sep 18th 2019
EXTRACT: "This is some of Ilic’s best work. A California native of Serbian extraction, he is emerging now as a major player in a crowded field."
Sep 8th 2019
Extract: "Chopin’s two piano concertos are among the most frequently recorded of 19th century works, both for their melodic charm, their pulsing rhythms and their historical significance. Young Chopin wrote the piano part with exceptional verve, showing the way for future composers to let the piano burst free from its orchestral surroundings."
Sep 8th 2019
Extract: "David Fray looked surprisingly alert when he arrived for a 7:30 a.m. breakfast interview at a comfortable inn outside of La Roque d’Anthéron in the south of France. We had both been at a midnight dinner following his performance at the famous piano festival. I left the dinner early with a colleague but he stayed till 3:00 chatting and laughing with the violinist he had just performed with, his friend Renaud Capuçon. Their Bach sonatas and a Bach piano concerto were the highlights of the evening. Over breakfast (David ate a bowl of chocolate-flavored cereal sweetened with ample spoonfuls of Nutella) we indulged a few minutes of smalltalk, then got down to business. He responded lucidly in French to some heavy questioning. He only stumbled once, at the end, when I asked him,  “What does music really mean to you?” His reply, ”That’s a big subject for so early in the morning!” But he continued searching for the words, and he found them."
Aug 31st 2019
François-Frédéric Guy was just finishing his 20th performance at the piano festival of La Roque d’Anthéron in the south of France. The 2,200-seat outdoor amphitheater was almost full as Guy displayed his love of Beethoven –playing two of his greatest sonatas, No. 16 and No. 26 (“Les Adieux”). After intermission, Guy took his place at the Steinway grand again and rattled the audience with the stormy opening bars of the Hammerklavier sonata. It was like a thunderclap, as Beethoven intended. The audience sat up straight and listened in stunned silence. There were more surprises to come. Guy’s first encore was the little bagatelle “Letter for Elise”. A titter ran through the amphitheater. Was he joking? He looked out over the crowd and smiled back. A few bars into the piece, total silence descended once again on the crowd as Guy brought out the depth and beauty of little “Elise”. Everyone thought they knew this piece by heart. They were wrong. No one had heard it quite like this. Huge applause erupted a few seconds after the last note. Several spectators near me wiped away tears from their eyes.