Dec 4th 2013

Alkan’s piano works return after decades of neglect

by Michael Johnson

Michael Johnson is a music critic with particular interest in piano. 

Johnson worked as a reporter and editor in New York, Moscow, Paris and London over his journalism career. He covered European technology for Business Week for five years, and served nine years as chief editor of International Management magazine and was chief editor of the French technology weekly 01 Informatique. He also spent four years as Moscow correspondent of The Associated Press. He is the author of five books.

Michael Johnson is based in Bordeaux. Besides English and French he is also fluent in Russian.

You can order Michael Johnson's most recent book, a bilingual book, French and English, with drawings by Johnson:

“Portraitures and caricatures:  Conductors, Pianist, Composers”

 here.

French composer Charles-Valentin Alkan, a member of the Liszt-Chopin circle and one of the most respected piano virtuosos of his day, is back with us after decades of neglect.  The occasion for his return is the 200th anniversary of his birth, and two striking CDs of his compositions have been recently released as a tribute.

Music commentators disagree on Alkan’s worth. He was described by Hans von Bulow as “the Berlioz of the piano” while others, including a Paris radio commentator just this week, find him “vacuous and uninspired, not at all in the Liszt-Chopin league”.  The Frenchman ended by saying “I don’t like him.” 

Personally, I need about ten hearings of any new composer before I can make up my mind, and these two pianists, Allessandro Deljavan and Pascal Amoyel, rewarded me with many arresting passages.  Alkan’s music got better and better as he settled into my mind. But I would say that both extremes of commentary have a point. He can be as sharp and musical as Berlioz and at times he can be as vacuous and uninspired as a mediocre artist.

Amoyel’s advice is blunt and straightforward. He writes in his liner notes: “If you are only half-hearted about Alkan’s music, it’s better not to play it.  It requires a huge musical, physical and intellectual investment. This is undoubtedly why his music is performed so rarely today.” 

Deljevan passes no judgment but observes that playing Alkan is no easy task. It requires “dazzling virtuosity, extreme velocity, enormous leaps at speed, long stretches of repeated notes and widely spaced contrapuntal lines”. All that is true.

The selections from Alkan’s large output are completely different on these two CDs but each has its separate appeal. 

Deljevan, the young Italian who created a stir at the recent Cliburn Piano Competition by being prematurely ejected, has tackled in his album “Alkan” (Piano Classics) the most challenging of the Alkan oeuvre, the Grandes Etudes, which include parts for left-hand only and parts for the right hand, plus, of course, most of the work calling for both hands.

The influences of Chopin – particularly the Nocturnes – and Liszt are evident, along with echoes of Beethoven in the first Etude, the left-handed Fantaisie. Dense chords and rapid virtuoso runs highlight the etudes, forcing the listener to strain to take it all in. 

In Deljevan’s hands, the effort is worth it. He has such a musical touch that any music – even Alkan’s – is made to sound romantic and supple.

Amoyel’s CD (La Dolce Volta LDV 11, distributed by Harmonia Mundi) opens with the Nocturne Opus 22 that draws upon John Field as much as Chopin. The inspiration is strikingly obvious and Amoyel, an outstanding Chopin player, is at home here. His liner notes point out a player’s difficulties with Alkan’s scores. “Sometimes, he writes, “certain passages do not seem playable, there are so many notations on the score.” 

Amoyel did not avoid the most daunting works, featuring the Grande Sonate Opus 33 and the charming Esquisses, opus 63. But the track that impressed me most was the “strange and extraordinary” Chanson de la folle au bord de la mer, opus 31 No. 8.  This extract from Alkan’s 25 preludes casts a gloomy spell with its lugubrious, heavy bass combined with an eerie melody in the upper register.

Amoyel says Alkan’s music is for the inquisitive, atypical keyboard artist. I would say the same goes for the listener, and thankfully there are many of us out there.




  

 


This article is brought to you by the author who owns the copyright to the text.

Should you want to support the author’s creative work you can use the PayPal “Donate” button below.

Your donation is a transaction between you and the author. The proceeds go directly to the author’s PayPal account in full less PayPal’s commission.

Facts & Arts neither receives information about you, nor of your donation, nor does Facts & Arts receive a commission.

Facts & Arts does not pay the author, nor takes paid by the author, for the posting of the author's material on Facts & Arts. Facts & Arts finances its operations by selling advertising space.

 

 

Browse articles by author

More Music Reviews

Feb 2nd 2015
Leonard Bernstein said, “The nineteenth century dies hard.” By that he meant his American concert-going audience would rather hear the lush, romantic music of over a hundred years ago —Tchaikovsky, Brahms and Verdi — than the angular, anguished music of the twentieth —Stravinsky, Schoenberg, S
Jan 25th 2015

I left jazz behind many years ago when I got hooked on Handel. The harmonies, the bounce and the melodies of the old German seemed to hold much more promise. I remember boasting to a friend, “I even have The Messiah in English.” I had a lot to learn. 

Jan 20th 2015

As composer Morton Feldman enjoys a comeback in contemporary music circles today, a Swiss arts and design academy has published a new tribute to him along with a CD featuring an ethereal interpretation of Palais de Mari, Feldman’s last solo piano work.

Jan 17th 2015

French pianist Hélène Grimaud returned to Bordeaux Friday night (Jan.

Jan 17th 2015

One would think that a reliable warhorse like “Tosca” might be a dull affair because it is performed so often, but the most recent Seattle Opera production shows that Puccini’s masterpiece still can grip audiences in the gut.

Jan 15th 2015
Even casual fans of classical music know of Ludwig van Beethoven’s deafness.  But could his hearing loss actually have been his greatest advantage as a musician?

Maybe so, says Leif Ove Andsnes, the highly acclaimed Norwegian pianist touring th

Jan 2nd 2015

The one thing the blogosphere does not need is another article about trendy, hip, ironic, facially-haired Brooklyn. In fact some recent articles now toll the death knell of the borough, saying that Brooklyn is passé; it seems that Queens is the new Brooklyn.

Dec 28th 2014

A powerful new recording of Rachmaninov’s familiar Sonata for Cello and Piano in G Minor Op. 19 (Light and Shadow, Becsta Records) manages to take this rich Russian music to new heights. It ranks comfortably alongside several impressive readings by other major cellists.

Dec 12th 2014

Marc-André Hamelin, Canadian-born and now residing in the Boston suburbs, has just completed a highly successful two-concert series in Bordeaux, playing the Beethoven piano concerto No. 4 including his own cadenza.

Dec 11th 2014

Canadian-born pianist Marc-André Hamelin kept a Bordeaux audience riveted Wednesday evening (Dec. 10) by his super-sensitive rendering of a familiar warhorse, the Beethoven piano concerto No. 4. Familiar, yes, but Bordeaux had never heard it performed quite so perfectly.

Dec 10th 2014

Canadian-born virtuoso pianist Marc-André Hamelin, looking relaxed and happy about his debut in Bordeaux this week, took time out between rehearsals at the city’s new concert hall, l’Auditorium, to talk about his past and what is coming next.

Nov 29th 2014

As any honest critic will tell you (if you can find one), writing about contemporary piano  is a long and thorny process requiring multiple hearings or multiple arguments with the composer.

Nov 27th 2014

You don’t have to be Irish to fall in love with music from the Emerald Isle.

Nov 20th 2014

The fifth annual Bordeaux piano festival, l’Esprit du Piano, concludes nine days of keyboard music on Friday Nov. 21 with Henri Barda playing works by Mozart, Brahms and Chopin.

Nov 18th 2014

Conducting is essentially a phenomenon associated with Western classical music. As a rule, rock and jazz bands do not employ a conductor unless they are teaming up with a symphony orchestra.
Nov 8th 2014

The NEC Philharmonia’s world premiere performance of Leon Kirchner’s retouched version of his charming Music for Flute and Orchestra arrived at Jordan Hall Wednesday with the popular Paula Robison and her gold flute.

Nov 6th 2014

It wasn’t so long ago that many musicians feared the piano was losing its way in serious music. The repertoire had not grown significantly in the 1950s and 1960s, and technology was increasingly favored by composers on the cutting edge.

Oct 2nd 2014
Abba - Knowing me, knowing you

I’m quite used to receiving abuse concerning the content of this column, but in contrast my previous post (about

Sep 30th 2014

In the hit parade of operas, Puccini’s La Bohème rates a solid third place after La Traviata and Carmen, so it was pretty much guaranteed a rousing reception as the opener of the new season in Bordeaux last week.